Some states’ economies cool even as the nation’s sizzles

Tim Henderson | Stateline.org (TNS)

A still-roaring nationwide economic system grew at an unexpectedly strong 5.2% annual price within the third quarter of this 12 months, however early indicators present a extra combined image for a lot of states heading into the vacations.

The preliminary unemployment price rose in 38 states and financial output slowed in 32 states in October, in accordance with a Stateline evaluation of preliminary federal financial information. Yet states the place the economic system remains to be buzzing — reminiscent of Arizona, Florida, North Carolina, Texas and Virginia — have added a whole lot of 1000’s of jobs since 2020 and are serving to to maintain nationwide output robust.

Economists be aware that the uptick within the jobless price could also be the results of long-inactive employees looking for jobs; these job-searchers are included within the unemployment price.

Most economists surveyed by Stateline mentioned the states with elevated unemployment charges and lagging manufacturing have been experiencing rising pains as they proceed to get better from the pandemic. A modest slowdown may even be a very good factor if it cools rates of interest and inflation, they mentioned.

“We’re not falling off the top of a flight of stairs, we’re only falling off the first step,” mentioned EJ Antoni, an economist on the conservative Heritage Foundation. Unemployment is certain to tick up as extra employees sidelined by the pandemic begin on the lookout for work, he added.

“One of the reasons why unemployment is so low is that there are something like 5 million people missing from the labor force,” Antoni mentioned. “The labor market never returned to its pre-pandemic trend.”

The labor power has shrunk since 2020 in 19 states — with particularly dramatic drops in California, Maryland, New York, Ohio and Massachusetts, in accordance with the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Meanwhile, manufacturing employment, usually used as an indicator of financial well being, dipped in October as a result of some autoworkers have been on strike.

States’ tax revenues

A slowdown within the economic system may very well be dangerous information for states which have already suffered declining tax income for greater than a 12 months. Many legislatures minimize taxes this 12 months in response to strong tax income development in fiscal years 2021 and 2022; these lawmakers now could have to trim spending agendas knowledgeable by rosier forecasts.

California, for instance, needed to minimize $8 billion in spending in this 12 months’s funds and delay different packages to cowl a $32 billion deficit; Maryland just lately introduced across-the-board transportation funds cuts due to ballooning deficits.

Meanwhile, still-booming states are reacting in a different way: Virginia embarked on new tax cuts mixed with main spending in September as a part of a bipartisan funds compromise. In November, Texas Republicans proposed spending a $2.7 billion tax windfall on border safety and schooling.

Nationally, state tax income has been declining for 14 straight months and was down 5.6% in September in contrast with the 12 months earlier than, in accordance with information compiled by the left-leaning Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. Early October experiences present “continued weakness” for many states, although a current inventory market turnaround could assist states for the remainder of the 12 months, mentioned Lucy Dadayan, principal analysis affiliate on the middle.

“The stock market improved a bit in the months of October and November and that might improve income tax revenues,” Dadayan wrote in an e-mail. “A lot depends on the stock market performance in December.”

But Dadayan additionally pointed to different indicators of hassle for state economies and tax income: Home value development is slowing, company earnings are falling, and there are fewer public choices to raise inventory costs.

As of October, California’s unemployment price was 4.8%, in contrast with 4.1% in October 2022. That is the third highest within the nation, behind solely Nevada and the District of Columbia.

Chas Alamo, a fiscal and coverage analyst for the California Legislative Analyst’s Office, referred to as California’s unemployment will increase a hazard signal for different states.

“There were 26 states with significant changes and all of them were increases in the unemployment rate — not a single decrease. That struck me as an unambiguous signal,” Alamo mentioned in an e-mail.

California’s year-over-year month-to-month unemployment price has been up by a minimum of half some extent for eight months in a row. There have been comparable spikes in New Jersey (additionally eight months in a row) and the District of Columbia (9 months) by October.

Despite a better unemployment price in New Jersey, “there are still more job openings than unemployed New Jersey residents,” mentioned state labor division spokesperson Angela Delli Santi. More folks looking for work is an indication of optimism, she mentioned, and extra persons are returning to the state labor power.

Nationally, the variety of people who find themselves neither working nor on the lookout for work remains to be about 4.8 million greater than in early 2020, in accordance with federal information.

Fifteen states, together with California, Illinois and New York, have fewer jobs than they did in early 2020.

State GDP figures

New state-by-state estimates of gross home product for the primary half of the 12 months, launched Dec. 5, have been excellent news for some states — California’s economic system, for instance, continued to increase regardless of recession fears. And Georgia, Hawaii, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, Ohio and West Virginia bounced again from first-quarter losses to second-quarter good points. Only Delaware, Mississippi and Wisconsin suffered inflation-adjusted drops in GDP by June of this 12 months.

However, state financial indexes maintained by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia confirmed 32 states with decrease financial output anticipated in October than September, although these numbers might change as information is revised. (For occasion, in October 2022, the preliminary information confirmed 27 states in decline, however after two revisions solely 12 states confirmed a lower that month, in accordance with the Stateline evaluation.)

Many of the nation’s largest states usually are not among the many 32 states the place GDP is believed to have declined in October. The economic system expanded in California, Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, Pennsylvania and Texas that month.

However, Arizona, Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, New Jersey, New York, Ohio and Virginia have been amongst these the place the economic system contracted.

Individual state economies could be considerably affected by native industries.

In California, a state report co-written by Alamo in October mentioned the state appeared to have had a “mild recession” from the final quarter of 2022 to the primary quarter of 2023, noting that there’s no formal definition for a state-level recession. The report cited a drop-off in tech funding, fewer house gross sales and regional financial institution failures as elements.

“The slowdown is suggestive of the importance of the technology and housing sectors to the vitality of the state’s economy,” the report concluded.

Washington state, one other know-how middle internet hosting giants reminiscent of Microsoft and Amazon, has fared higher than California, recovering jobs misplaced within the pandemic extra rapidly and seeing decrease unemployment this 12 months. Washington’s jobless price is 3.8%, down from 4.6% in October 2022.

Rural areas of Washington state recovered extra rapidly than Seattle, mentioned Anneliese Vance-Sherman, the state’s chief labor economist. There are extra industries deemed “essential” reminiscent of well being care and agriculture in these communities, whereas Seattle suffered from extra tech layoffs and declines in companies that rely on commuters, reminiscent of eating places.

A slight enhance in unemployment in current months for Washington state may very well be a wholesome growth if it means some employees are coming again to the job market, Vance-Sherman mentioned.

“For Washington state, much of the recent rise in the unemployment rate stems not from people losing their jobs but from new people entering or reentering the workforce,” she mentioned.

Stateline is a part of States Newsroom, a nationwide nonprofit information group targeted on state coverage.

©2023 States Newsroom. Visit at stateline.org. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.